Music Blog

BBC NEWS | Entertainment | Music | Hendrix tops guitar greats poll
Yet another “Greatest Guitarist” poll, with a totally predicatable poll winner. The rest of this list is pretty predictable too; the usual suspects Jimmy Page and Eric Clapped-Out (both of whom I consider overrated).

The article makes an interesting point about the fact that only one woman (Tracy Chapman) made top 100

Rowley said women were not as “geeky or competitive” about music as men.

“Instead of showing off, they’re trying to write a good song. Which is probably smarter,” he added.

Maybe; but maybe it’s because lead guitar is a very, well male thing.

At the moment I’m having great difficulty thinking of any significant women rock musicians. Singers, yes, but not musicians. In comparison, the classical world has a great number of female soloists. Where is the rock equivalent of Vanessa Mae (who reminds me of a female Yngwie Malmsteen!)?

BBC NEWS | Entertainment | Led Zeppelin star ‘fled gig’
Amusing story – Robert Plant goes to see a Led Zeppellin tribute band, and flees when fans recognise him. He claims he was worried about being dragged up on stage to sing “Battle of Evermore”. Could have been worse, Robert; they might have wanted you to sing “Stairway!”.

Having volunteered for Blogcritics.com (see Eric Olsen’s blog for more about this), I must decide what to review in time for the launch. Searching through recent purchases, I’ve come up with these four from the last couple of months. At the moment I’m unsure which of these to go for as my sample review for the site’s launch. (I’ll add a lot more, including a track-by-track review of the one I’ve chosen). Or perhaps go out and buy something completely new. As ever, your comments will be appreciated.

Rush – Vapor Trails

I’ve been a fan of Rush since the beginning of the 80s. One of the great bands of the 70s, 80s and 90s, Rush had been on hold for several years while drummer and lyricist Neil Peart recovered from being devastated by the deaths of both his wife and his daughter within a few months of each other. While bandmates Alex Lifeson and Geddy Lee had both recorded solo albums in the interim, the return of Rush to active service has been eagerly awaited by all fans of the band.

This album isn’t what you might expect. They’ve made a deliberate decision on this album not to use any keyboards, and to have no conventional guitar solos. The latter will no doubt be a disappoinment to fans of Alex Lifeson’s fluid style, but there are plenty of other things to recommend about this album.

The album opener, “One Little Victory” starts with a fusillade of drums, just to remind us all the Neil Peart is back. This intro, especially when joined by Geddy Lee’s bass, reminds me of Motorhead’s “Overkill”, although the intro is as far as the comparison goes.

Overall, I’m not sure how to sum up this album. It’s not Rush’s best, no “Moving Pictures” or “Hemispheres”. But Rush have never been a band to retread their own past.

Rhapsody – Power of the Dragonflame

Fourth full-length album by Italy’s “Symphonic Epic Hollywood Metal”, it’s another slab of operatic pomp-metal with lyrics so strongly influenced by DnD you can almost hear the polyhedral dice rolling.

Really should be released under the d20 licence – Requires the Dungeons and Dragons Player’s Handbook in order to listen.

Arjen Anthony Lucassen’s Star One – Space Metal

New project by the Holland’s Arjen Lucassen, the man behind Ayreon. This album sees Arjen steering more towards melodic metal rather than progressive metal of Ayreon, with lyrics inspired by easily-recognisable science-fiction films and novels. The heavy sound, with a lot of hammond organ in places, should appeal a lot to fans of Uriah Heep, although the 80s sheen on the production sounds a bit dated at times.

Muse – Hullabaloo

My only recent album purchase by a fashionable young band who’s members weren’t even born when I started collecting records. A double album, the first disk made up of collection of B-sides and outtakes, the second a live performance in Paris. I’m amazed at the combination of energy and virtuosity of this trio, with some great neo-classical guitar flourishes, and some fantastic keyboard work as well. The vocal style invites comparison with Radiohead in parts.

Meanwhile, in the news

This news story about the “vampire murderer” from Anglesey is worrying. Not that the murder isn’t shocking (and 12 years seems a light sentence for murder), but what worries me is the conclusions more hysterical sections of the media are likely to come to. I would expect the ever-toxic Daily Mail to call for the immediate banning of role-playing games, heavy metal music, and the Internet. After all, the Daily Mail is more dangerous than, say The Sun, because unlike the red-tops, the Mail‘s readers seem to take that paper’s Manichean world-view seriously.

Why is it when something bad is done by someone from an obscure sub-culture (heavy metal fans, roleplayers, train-spotters, what have you), that subculture is placed under a distorted microscope and blamed?. When a boy-racer runs kills someone when driving at three times the speed limit, or a football hooligan stabs a rival fan to death, the media doesn’t blame car culture or football in general.

I would guess boy-racers are responsible for far more deaths than wannabe-vampires…

A lot of webloggers, such as Bruce Baugh and Eric Olsen have been talking about the file-sharing recently. The recording business, an industry notirious for ripping off consumers and screwing over it’s creative talent, loathes file-swapping services such as Napster, and blames them for declining music sales. They’re even proposing highly dubious laws (via their bought-and-paid-for US politicians) enabling them to hack into and destroy other people’s systems to stop file-sharing.

The music business of course claims that they’re losing sales because people download MP3s instead of buying CDs, and seem to believe that every MP3 downloaded represents a lost sale. I can remember them using the same argument against cassette recorders in the late 70s and early 80s. I wasn’t convinced by those arguments then, and I’m even less convinced now. And people tell me they’ve tried this argument against FM radio as well.

Eric Olsen’s blog reprints an interview with Janis Ian, in which she claims that file-sharing is actually increasing her sales of CDs. With so much commercial radio following a narrow top-40 or golden oldie format, non-mainstream artists can’t get their work heard. Internet file sharing lets people sample their work, and translates into CD sales.

I’m increasingly thinking the real reason the major record companies loathe file-sharing is that they don’t want this to happen. Their business model is based on a small number of million-selling artists, like N’Sync and Britney Spears, boosted by massive amounts of hype. The less talented and more manufactured the better, so they realise they’re totally dependant on the company and won’t insist on silly things like ‘artistic freedom’. The last thing they want is the finite money people have to spend on music dissipated amongst millions of independant artists. Worse still, to artists not signed to major record companies, but selling direct to their audience via the internet. The horror! People might start listening to Marillion or Uriah Heep.

An Estonian group is recording medieval-sounding versions of Black Sabbath songs in Latin. Their album contains songs such as “Rotae Confusionis” and “Verres Militares” in slow, minimalist versions that wouldn’t seem out of place in the Sistine Chapel, according to Yahoo. Their official site is www.sabbatum.com if you want to know more.

Thanks to mediageeklife for this link: The 50 worst guitar solos of all time This list is highly suspect – what on earth is Dave Gilmour’s sublime ‘Comfortably Numb’ solo doing on there? And where is Jeff Beck’s truly bad solo from ‘Hi Ho Silver Lining? Nice to see the grossly-overrated Eric Clapped-out at #1, though

I’ve finally managed to find (thanks to my brother) some information on the Polish goth-metal band, Closterkeller. While my brother was working as an ESL teacher in Poland he bought me back a couple of their albums as Christmas and birthday presents. The music is a strange mixture of goth, new wave and metal influences, sung entirely in Polish. The band, as far as I know, are virtually unknown outside of their native Poland, making those albums some of the more interesting things in my record collection.

“Will you tell me where my country lies”
Says the unifaun to his true love’s eyes
“It lies with me” says the Queen of Maybe
for her merchandise he traded in his prize

They don’t write them like that any more!

It is, as any self-respecting fan of prog-rock should know, the opening lines of ‘Dancing with the Moonlit Knight’ from Genesis’ classic 1973 album ‘Selling England by the Pound’. After seeing The Musical Box a couple of months ago, I’ve finally got round to getting the album on CD (My old vinyl copy is gathering dust at my parents’ place back in Slough). I’d forgotten just how good it was.

The cloth-eared music journalists who inanely claim that ‘Punk was created to save us from music like this’ just don’t know what they’re talking about. Forget the banal stadium-rock that Genesis churned out for the people who don’t really like music much in the 1980s, it was during the Peter Gabriel years in the early 1970s the they produced some of the most creative and sublime music ever to emerge from the British rock scene.

With roots that owed far more to English classical and folk music than American blues, and complex songs with running times running to ten minutes or more, it’s never going appeal to the sorts of people that prefer three-minute songs you can dance to. But it has other pleasures; just listen to Steve Hackett’s emotive and quite un-blues like guitar solo on ‘Firth of Fifth’, and Peter Gabriel’s distinctive (if surreal) lyrics and melodies throughout the entire album, and Tony Banks dramatic keyboard workout of ‘Cinema Show’. The only low spot is Phil Collins’ maudlin ballad ‘More Fool Me’, a grim foretaste of the dire drivel he would inflict upon the world in the 1980s and beyond. With a running time of 53 minutes it’s a very long album for 1973, when 35-40 minute albums were the norm.

New on Kalyr.com

A page on my current N-gauge project, Wominsee. Currently just a trackplan and some notes; I will add some photos as construction progresses.

In memory of John Entwhistle of The Who, who died yesterday aged 57, I’m playing “Live at Leeds” on the stereo as I type this.

While I’ve never been a huge Who fan, I still believe that John Entwhistle wasn’t just the bass player of a great band, he was a truly great bass player, perhaps the best of his generation. Just listen to “The Real Me” off “Quadrophenia”. While Pete Townshend is bashing out chords, basically playing rhythm guitar, John is effectively playing the lead line on the bass.

He will be missed.

Also in the news

In this Guardian article, Polly Toynbee wonders if it’s time for America to stop lecturing to the rest of the world, especially us Europeans, how we should run our economies. After Enron, Worldcom and Xerox, is their deregulated wild west capitalism really the One True Way?

The bulbous-nosed king of the wah-wah pedal, Mick Box, has a brand new website, celebrating his 30+ years as guitarist and sole remaining founder member of Uriah Heep. (He’s the one in the middle on the picture on the top of this page) Just thought I’d mention it….