Record Reviews Blog

Album, EP and DVD reviews, with an emphasis on the UK progressive rock scene.

Mermaid Kiss – Etarlis

There seem to almost as many British female-fronted progressive bands as there are symphonic metal bands on the continent. I first heard of this band from a discussion on the Mostly Autumn forum, where it was recommended strongly enough that I ordered the album. After a few spins, it turned out to be a very worthwhile purchase indeed.

“Etarlis” is actually Mermaid Kiss’s third album. According to the liner notes, the songs are inspired by a fantasy adventure written over the years by Jamie Field and Evelyn Downing. It’s an epic tale of heroism and war rather than a parochal tale about fights outside the chip shop.

The keyboard-led music is strongly atmospheric and pastoral, with sparing use of lead guitar, significant use of flute, supplemented in places by oboe and cor anglais. The haunting melodies come from two distinctively different lead vocalists; Kate Belcher’s pure tones contrasting with Evelyn Downing’s more expressive style.

The closest musical reference point is probably the original incarnation of Karnataka, indeed Jonathan Edwards, formerly of Karnataka and now The Panic Room makes a guest appearance with a keyboard solo on ‘A Sea Change’. Troy Donockley.adds some uilleann pipes on the same track.

If you’re into celtic/ambient progressive rock with female vocals, you won’t go wrong by getting hold of this album. It’s available from the band’s website, www.mermaidkiss.co.uk.

Posted in Music, Record Reviews | Tagged , | Comments Off

Breathing Space – Coming Up For Air

Just after their excellent set at the Mostly Autumn Convention back in March, I remarked to bassist Paul Teasdale that in a couple of years time they might be giving Mostly Autumn a run for their money. A few minutes later the Mostlies launched into an absolute blinder of a set that seemed to emphasise for me the qualification ‘in a couple of years time’.

Just seven months later Breathing Space come up with an album that quite possibly tops the last Mostly Autumn release Heart Full of Sky.

Coming Up for Air isn’t really a prog album. There are no 12 minute songs about Hobbits on this one. It’s a quite commercial-sounding set with an 80s pop feel in places, evenly split between up-tempo pop/rock numbers and the sort of gorgeous sweeping ballads Iain Jennings used to write for Mostly Autumn. There’s no filler, and Iain has done a superb production job; the sound is crystal clear, and the tight arrangements don’t waste a note.

If the first album was really an Iain Jennings solo release, this one is very much a band effort, with writing credits shared between Iain Jennings, Olivia Sparnenn and Mark Rowan. Olivia’s vocals show how much she’s improved as a singer in the two years since the first album, and I’m seriously impressed by Mark Rowan’s guitar work. He’s not flashy, but every one of his solos fit the song perfectly. The album also features guest appearances from Liam Davidson, who contributes some soaring slide guitar on “Don’t Turn a Blind Eye”, and from John Hart, who contributes sax and flute.

Standouts are many; I love the beautiful “Rain Song”, a reworking of a song performed by Livvy and Chris Johnson when they supported Mostly Autumn two years ago. Another standout is “Searching for my Shadow”, another song of Livvy’s, with an instrumental section that has more than a hint of “Carpe Diem” about it.

This is yet another addition to the growing list of great 2007 albums. It’s available direct from the band’s website – www.breathingspaceband.info

Posted in Music, Record Reviews | Tagged , | Comments Off

Apocalyptica – Worlds Collide

If you watched the Eurovision Song Contest, you might remember the bunch of hairy heavy metal cellists whose performance during the interval was by far the best music of the evening. You might also remember it being totally ruined by that moron Wogan prattling inanely over the top of them.

Despite the almost complete absence of guitars, they’re just released one of the most metal albums of the year. All those piledriving riffs are actually distorted cellos; it’s only when one of them plays a solo that they actually sound like a cellos. This is not a traditional string quartet.

With the exception of a cover of Bowie’s “Helden”, all the songs are originals. The album is a mix of instrumentals and songs featuring various guest vocalists, including Rammstein’s Til Linderman, and Lacuna Coil’s Christina Scabbia.If anything, I find I prefer the instrumentals; the title track and “Burn” being particular standouts.

Now, where did I put my air cello?

Posted in Music, Record Reviews | Tagged | 1 Comment

Fish – 13th Star

Whatever I feel about his recent behaviour, I’m still a fan of the former Marillion frontman’s music. And Fish has just come up with an absolute blinder of an album.

He finished recording his 13th album, 13th Star, in the aftermath of his very acrimonious split with Heather Findlay. He tends to produce his best work when he’s angry and bitter over something, so I was expecting him to deliver a strong album. Which he has.

Fish is primarily a singer and lyricist, and not much of a composer; therefore the quality of his albums depends very heavily on whoever he’s got as his songwriting partner. This time round, much of the music is written by bassist Steve Vantsis, who’s been with Fish’s band for years, but hasn’t had much in the way of writing credits before now.

Musically, parts of this album are very heavy, approaching metal in several places. Some songs have an industrial feel, with drum loops, heavily processed guitars, and groove-orientated basslines. The opening pair, ‘Circle Line‘ and ‘Square Go‘, are typical of this approach, In contrast, ‘Miles de Besos‘ and ‘Zoe 25‘ are more reflective keyboard-led numbers that wouldn’t have sounded out of place around the time of “Sunsets on Empire”.

Arc of the Curve‘ begins with the same opening line as his 1985 hit with Marillion, ‘Kayleigh‘, and the similarities, both musical and lyrical, don’t end there. From then on the album builds in intensity with the angry and emotionally charged ‘Machmal‘, the powerful driving rocker ‘Openwater‘ and ‘Dark Star‘, before winding down with the ballads ‘Where in the World‘ and the title track.

As for the lyrics, more than half the songs are directly about the breakup. With all the very unpleasant washing of dirty linen in the media at the time of the split, I had feared the worst. Had a large part of the album been an attack on Heather, I would have found it unlistenable, no matter how good it might have been musically. (As regular readers of this blog should know, I’m a huge fan of her music, and have met her several times) But while it does get uncomfortably personal on some lines of ‘Dark Star‘, most of the lyrics are concerned with his own feelings.

Fish isn’t the world’s best singer by any means. And nowadays he lacks the range he had in his younger years. He makes up for this with his impassioned and emotional delivery; frustration, anger, sadness and ultimately hope.

This is very much an album that stands as a whole rather than a random collection of songs. Every song works in the context of the album, and There’s no filler at all. It’s certainly Fish’s best work since at least “Sunsets on Empire”, and is a very strong candidate for album of the year.

This album will not be available by retail until early 2008, it’s currently only sold online from The Fish Shop, or at gigs.

Ricky Carvel and The Ministry of Information have also reviewed this album.

Posted in Music, Record Reviews | Tagged , | 7 Comments

Odin Dragonfly – Offerings

I’ve finally got to listen to the long-awaited album by Odin Dragonfly, the acoustic side project of Mostly Autumn’s lead vocalist Heather Findlay and flautist/keyboard player Angela Gordon.

Back in February, I saw Odin Dragonfly live at Fibbers in York. I went knowing Heather and Angie from Mostly Autumn, but without having heard a note of their music as Odin Dragonfly, and not knowing quite what to expect. They won me over within the space of a couple of songs. I saw them again at the Mostly Autumn convention in March, after which I had several of their songs stuck in my head for weeks, notably “Magpie” and “Given Time”. There was something magical about their live performances.

Now they’ve successfully captured that magical sound in the recording studio.

This isn’t the sort of music I normally listen to. Definitely not ‘prog’, and not even rock, there’s not a Fender Stratocaster or Mellotron in sight. It’s 100% acoustic, with just guitar, piano, flute, penny whistle and two voices. But the result is something of stunning beauty. The signature sound is one of sublime vocal harmonies, with plenty of Angela Gordon’s flute, something which has been thin on the ground on recent Mostly Autumn releases. The piano and guitar accompaniment is understated but effective.

Eight of the twelve songs are originals, with the album rounded out with a couple of reworked Mostly Autumn tunes, and a pair of well-chosen covers, including their version of Jethro Tull’s “Witches Promise” with which they normally end their live shows.

Early favourites of mine are Angela Gordon’s piano-led “Given Time”, and Heather’s “Magpie” and “How I feel today”, both featuring wonderful interplay between Heather’s voice and Angela’s flute. Then there’s “Magnolia Half Moon”, a achingly sad breakup song that wouldn’t have sounded out of place on “Heart Full of Sky”, since it has quite a bit in common with “Half a World” both musically and lyrically. But this is one of those rare albums without any real filler, consistant from beginning to end.

You can order the album online from Odindragonfly.com

Posted in Music, Record Reviews | Tagged , | Comments Off

The Reasoning – Awakening

Another belated review. This one’s only two months old.

Cardiff’s The Reasoning are one of three bands to arise from the ashes of the original lineup of Karnataka, which imploded in 2004. The band includes Karnataka’s former lead vocalist Rachel Jones, and bassist Matt Cohen, formerly of Magenta. Their debut album was one of the most eagerly awaited for the first part of the year.

While the presence of Rachel Jones is invitably going to draw comparisons with her previous band, musically The Reasoning are a quite different beast. Compared to Karnataka’s atmospheric keyboard-driven sound, The Reasoning’s twin guitar lineup is more prog-tinged melodic hard rock than atmopheric celtic prog. And do they indeed rock out on this album.

It’s well-produced album with a crisp, clear sound courtesy of Dave Meegan of Marillion fame. Rachel shares lead vocal duties with Dylan Thomson, who I’ve heard compared with Frances Dunnery of It Bites, and the fact the Dylan sings more lead than Rachel is perhaps the album’s only fault. Several of the songs get stuck in the brain after just a couple of listens, notably “Aching Hunger”, “Fallen Angels” and the atmopheric “Sacred Shape”, perhaps the closest-sounding song to Karnataka, despite being sung by Dylan. Celtic prog sounds also surface in the album closer “Within Cold Glass” which features guest appearances from Marillion’s Steve Rothery and The Bluehorses Liz Prendergast.

For a debut album, this is an impressive piece of work. I look forward to the followup, to be recorded in the new year.

Posted in Music, Record Reviews | Tagged , | 1 Comment

Mostly Autumn – Heart Full of Sky

I’ve been very remiss on album reviews this year. Something like half a dozen good albums have come out in the first four months of 2007, and I haven’t posted reviews of a single one of them. This is the oldest one in the backlog. Officially released in February, I had the limited pre-order edition since before Christmas. So I’ve been living with this album for something like five months now, and heard the bulk of live several times, so it’s had more than enough time to sink in.

It’s an album that appears to have divided with the fanbase; although it’s been well-received by the majority, there’s a vocal minority that still strongly dislike it. I suppose this is inevitable for any band that refuses to tread water musically; this work is definitely not a retread of any period of the band’s past. It’s not a repeat of “Storms Over Still Water” or “Passengers”, nor is it return to the style of the much loved (by some) early albums.

Saying that, it is probably their most varied album since their 1996 debut. Opener “Fading Colours” has to be the most powerful hard rocker Mostly Autumn have ever recorded. A few bars at the beginning strongly recall Rainbow’s “Eyes of the World”, and the rest of the song has a similar feel. Other highlights are the lengthy “Walk With a Storm”, part epic hard rocker, part electifying celtic jig featuring guest musicians Peter Knight and Troy Donockley on violin and uilleann pipes, Heather’s heartfelt “Half a World”, and the achingly sad “Find the Sun”, also featuring Peter Knight’s violin.

Several songs break new ground for the band, such as the sparse “Broken”, just piano and Heather’s voice, and Chris Johnson’s hauntingly beautiful “Silver Glass”. Then there’s the largely instrumental “Further from Home”, six minutes of Bryan Josh putting that blue Stratocaster through it’s paces, and sounding like all the best bits of Dave Gilmour’s “On an Island” compressing into a single song.

The plodding sub-Oasis “Pocket Watch” is the album’s only real dud. There are hundreds of other interchangeable bands doing this sort of three chord nonsense, and Mostly Autumn shouldn’t be wasting their time trying to copy them.

Other quibbles are minor; I’d like to have heard more of Angela Gordon’s flute, which is almost completely absent this time around. And a couple of songs, such as “Ghost” and the closing epic “Dreaming” might have benefitted from a little more time polishing up the arrangments. But overall it’s a very strong album, even if it’s not quite the masterpiece I believe the band are capable of. If “Storms Over Still Water” marked a step change in Bryan Josh’s guitar playing, this one shows the same sort of improvement in Heather’s lead vocals; I’ve never heard her sing better. And Chris Johnson has proved that he can fill the role of third songwriter left by the departure last year of Iain Jennings.

Posted in Music, Record Reviews | Tagged , | Comments Off

The Mars Volta – Amputecture

This album took me a while to get into. On the first couple of spins, I didn’t find the third studio album by Omar Rodriguez-Lopez, Cedric Bixler-Zavala and crew to be quite as immediate as the first two. However, it grows with repeated listens. And eventually, it’s worth it.

It’s got the same mixture bizarre of alternative, prog-rock and traditional Mexican music, and again features the guitar playing of John Frusciante. It starts slowly; the creepily atmospheric opener “Vicarious Atonement” begins with two minutes of fluid but spooky blues guitar before the equally spectral vocals come it. The following lengthy “Tetragrammaton” is much closer to The Mars Volta’s sound on earlier albums with its bursts of staccato guitar riffs and machine gun drumming interspersed with gentler moments and effects-laden instrumental sections. And there are several more where that came from. But there are some new elements; “Vermicide” is probably the nearest The Mars Volta will ever get to a power ballad. And breaking new territory is the sparse “Asilos Magdelena”, sung in Spanish, with just a naked acoustic guitar for most of the song.

Overall, it might lack some of the frenetic energy of their debut, “Deloused in the Comatorium”, but there’s plenty enough to reward the listener once you get beneath the skin of the record.

Posted in Music, Record Reviews | Tagged | Comments Off

Pure Reason Revolution – The Dark Third

PRR are one of the so-called “nu-prog” bands who have attracted the attention of some of the fashionable media. Quite why that same media focuses on completely new bands rather than those who have been ploughing an unfashionable furrow for years in an interesting question. Perhaps it’s because they’re signed to a major label and plugged into the Big Media hype machine. HippyDave has likened them to a prog version of The Darkness, and I suppose he’s got a point. Time will tell if they follow the same career trajectory, coming to earth with a crash after a poorly-received ‘difficult second album’.

I realise that so far I’ve said nothing about the actual music. In fact, it’s rather good. A lot of prog tropes are present and correct; 12 minute multi-part epics, soaring vocal harmonies, and song titles like “Apprentice of the Universe” and “The Bright Ambassadors of Morning”. The album opens with some very Meddle like slide guitar on the instrumental “Aeropause”, and the rest of the album continues to show a strong Pink Floyd influence. The vocal arrangements with twin lead vocalists Chloe Alper and John Courtney are particularly impressive throughout, and the whole thing is immaculately played and produced. The only thing missing is that there are no real solos. Sure, it’s a bit derivative in places, but tell me what isn’t nowadays. Whatever they might achieve in the future, I like this album a lot.

Posted in Music, Record Reviews | Tagged | Comments Off

Mew – And the Glass Handed Kites/Riverside – Second Life Syndrome

Mew: And the Glass Handed Kites

Mew have been tipped as one of the ‘new progressive’ bands who take influences from 70s progressive rock and make them relevant to the 21st century. Unfortunately the only ‘prog’ thing about this record are the wierd song titles and incomprehensible lyrics. Musically the progressive influences are so diluted they might as well not be there. What we do get is a whole load of generic indie-style jangling guitar (I hate that style of guitar playing) leavened by very occasional prog-style keyboard flourishes. A couple of beautiful soaring vocal lines rise above the jangly morass, but it’s not enough to save the album. For my tastes at any rate, this one’s something of a dud. Serves me right for trusting the judgement of the rock critics of The Guardian. I’m half convinced that they just read the lyrics booklets and never bother to listen to the actual records.

Riverside: Second Life Syndrome

Poland’s Riverside most likely aren’t even on radar screen of the indie-obsessed Guardian scribblers, but unlike Mew, they’re the real thing. I’m writing this on a wet and miserable morning in Manchester, and the music seems to be a perfect fit to the weather. Some of the cold and bleak soundscapes evoke what I imagine Poland must be like in the depths of winter. The guitar-driven music is reminiscent of some recent Porcupine Tree, although they’ve enough of their own identity to avoid becoming a simple pastiche. I can also hear echoes of a stripped-down Dream Theater in places. Piotr Grunzinski’s masterful guitar playing defines their sound, all angular riffs and fluid soloing; no indie-style jangling to be heard. It’s a perfect match for Maruisz Duda’s somewhat angst-ridden lyrics. We could probably have done without the rather clichéd ‘Shine on You Crazy Diamond’ intro to the 15 minute title track, but that’s a minor quibble, it’s only a minute and a half of their whole album.

Posted in Music, Record Reviews | Tagged , , | 1 Comment