Record Reviews Blog

Album, EP and DVD reviews, with an emphasis on the UK progressive rock scene.

Crimson Sky – Dawn

Crimson Sky - DawnBristol-based rock band Crimson Sky established a reputation with the 2009′s album “Misunderstood” and some well-received gigs including a strong performance at the 2010 Cambridge Rock Festival. Unfortunately that lineup of the band imploded soon after, and for a while the continued existence of the band was in doubt.

After a lengthy hiatus the band regrouped earlier this year with a brand new lineup featuring Jane Setter on vocals and Moray McDonald on keys. Following some successful gigs that proved the new-look band had what it takes, the band went into the studio to record a four-track EP; two brand new songs, and two reworkings of songs from “Misunderstood”.

The EP opens with an atmospheric keyboard drone accompanied by bells, which leads into the eastern-flavoured guitar figure that forms the intro to “Crimson Sky”, the first of two new numbers. By the time the full band kick in one thing that’s very apparent is the quality of the production; the sound is both polished and powerful. This is prog-rock with the emphasis on Rock.

Next comes the re-recording of lengthy ballad “The Sea”, featuring an extended guitar workout. The second new number “The Park” has the feel of slightly punky Uriah Heep with it’s organ riff and energetic vocal. The EP closes with “After the Rain” with something of an indie vibe with it’s jangling guitar, at least until we get to the solo.

Changing a vocalist always has a big impact on a band’s sound. In Crimson Sky’s case, Jane Setter neither copies the previous singer’s style nor completely changes the sound of the band. She’s got greater range, but although her background is more ‘classic rock’ there’s still a touch of 80s new-wave about her vocal style. She makes her mark on the old songs without radically reinterpreting them, and then goes on to show just what she can do on the new ones.

The dominant instrumental sound is still Martin Leamon’s fluid lead guitar. There are moments, especially on “The Sea” that remind me of Twelfth Night’s Andy Revell. The other thing that strongly impresses is Moray McDonald’s keyboard playing. Much is his playing is understated, adding colour rather than playing lead, but he shines on “The Park” with that great organ riff and some lovely piano later in the song. There’s more than a touch of Marillion’s Mark Kelly about his playing, especially his solo on “Crimson Sky”.

The end result is an impressive progressive rock record that manages to avoid most of the obvious clichés of the genre. Let’s hope it isn’t too long before the band follow it up with a full-length album.

Posted in Record Reviews | Tagged | 2 Comments

Muse – 2nd Law

Muse 2nd LawI’m sometimes accused of only liking obscure prog-rock bands who sing about Hobbits in 9/8 time. One Guardian music journalist who shall remain nameless has called me the “Prog Taliban” and claimed that I don’t like pop music.

So why am I reviewing a Muse album? Because, despite the fact that they’ve headlined the indie-centric Glastonbury Festival and you can probably get their albums in Asda, Muse are a really prog-rock band.

Opener “Supremacy” begins with a dirty Jack White style guitar riff accompanied by marching Dream Theater keyboards before moving to a classically-inspired vocal melody, with a guitar solo repeating the same motif. There’s something very Prog about the whole thing.

And it goes on like that. Yes, there still are plenty of homages to Queen, starting with the pseudo-dubstep “I Want To Break Free” of “Madness”. Then there’s the disco-funk of “Panic Station”. There are nods to U2. But “Animals”, with it’s wonderful rippling guitar could easily have come from a recent Marillion album. The wide-screen atmospherics of “Save Me” recall recent Anathema, and some of the guitars remind me of mid-period Genesis. The cinematic two-part title track that closes the album is just monstrous with it’s huge choirs and Pink Floyd-style voiceovers.

This is an album that mixes pop, metal, electronica with grandiose classical sweeps and arpeggios. A lot of it is bombastic and completely over the top, but it wouldn’t really be a Muse album if it wasn’t. They’ve got a pop sensibility; three or four minute songs with big choruses. But they pack so many musical ideas into those three or four minutes.

The way the album mixes bits of many different genres to produce something more than the sum of parts reminds me of Panic Room’s SKIN. Yes, there are obvious homages to other bands which have drawn comparisons with Oasis’ pillaging of rock history. But Muse draw from a far, far broader sonic palette than simple meat-and-potatoes guitar rock. The result is an album that ought to appeal to any self-respecting prog-rock fan.

Posted in Record Reviews | Tagged | 3 Comments

Mermaid Kiss – Another Country

Way back in 2008, Mermaid Kiss made quite a few live appearances supporting bands such as Panic Room and Breathing Space. They performed as a semi-acoustic lineup, playing a mix of stripped-down arrangements of songs from their 2007 album “Etarlis” and brand new material from a project with a working title of “American Images”. Four years later, that project has reached completion as their new album “Another Country”

It’s not a long album; with a running time of an 38 minutes it’s closer to an old-fashioned vinyl LP, and this time it’s a digital-only release. The theme is an imaginary journey through the America of music and film; the nation as seen though the eyes of someone who’s never actually been there. The American Images page on the band’s website tells the stories behind the songs

There’s a strong emphasis on acoustic instruments, with a lot of flute, cor anglais and acoustic guitar. With touches of gospel and Americana the sound is closer to those 2008 gigs than to the symphonic prog-rock sweep of their previous album. It’s all very song-focussed, there are no lengthy instrumental passages, although there are some brief interludes of piano and cor anglais. But neither is it an unplugged record; there are electric solos courtesy of lead guitarist Pete West, and Colin Henney’s less-is-more keyboards add some effective atmospherics. Good as those two are, if anything the best instrumental performances come from woodwind player Wendy Marks with some evocative playing that’s a major component of their signature sound.

High points include the spine-tingling “Dust Bowl Bride”, with it’s haunting melody, evocative choral sounds and beautiful flute solo, and the simple but effective ballad “Comes And Goes”, with another melody that gets stuck in your head.

Evelyn Downing has progressed a long way in four years as a vocalist, giving an especially strong performance on “This Trail of Tears”. This recording marks the end of her work with Mermaid Kiss, as the band begin work on a follow-up to “Etarlis” with new singer Maria Milewska. It will be interesting to see what projects Evelyn involves herself with next.

I like this album a lot. It takes them in a slightly different musical direction while still keeping enough of a continuity with their earlier work. It’s been a long time coming, but it’s worth the wait.

It’s available for download from CDBaby.

Posted in Record Reviews | Tagged | Comments Off

Riversea – Out Of The Ancient World

Riversea is a collaboration between singer/songwriter Marc Atkinson and keyboard player Brendan Eyre. It’s been a long time in the making, so long in fact it almost makes you wonder if the album title is a reference to how long ago since they started work on it.

Although the creative core of Riversea are a duo, it’s a full band project with a cast of guest musicians that reads like a who’s who of the somewhat incestuous York rock scene. It includes Alex Cromarty of The Heather Findlay Band on drums, Dave Clements on bass, and a whole host of guest guitarists, including Mostly Autumn’s Bryan Josh and Liam Davison, Stolen Earth’s Adam Dawson, and Mark Rowen, formerly of Breathing Space.

They have delivered a strongly song-orientated record, with a big, rich sound. Atkinson’s emotive vocals strongly recall Marillion’s Steve Hogarth, especially on the quieter parts. As one might expect, there’s an emphasis on keyboard-led arrangements ranging from simple piano accompaniments to heavy symphonic rock sections. Eyre tends to leave much of the soloing to the guest guitarists, whose differing styles add variety. Despite the presence of plenty of virtuoso musicians, there is little or no self-indulgent showboating for it’s own sake; all the solos and instrumental passages fit the song and never outstay their welcomes.

Highlights include the thought-provoking “Is This What God Wants”, and “Falling Stars” with it’s great heavy neo-prog instrumental break featuring one of Eyre’s few keyboard solos and an incredible guitar solo from by Adrian Jones. Others standouts are “The Song”, with the soaring vocal in the end section from Mostly Autumn’s Olivia Sparnenn, and “Freeze the Frame”, a lovely laid-back Pink Floyd feel, with some great guitar from former Breathing Space man Mark Rowen. But it’s hard to pick individual songs; this is really one of those albums where the quality is consistent throughout. There’s no filler here, the arrangements are thoroughly honed and polished, and nothing sounds half-finished or out of place.

With this, and the excellent albums by Mostly Autumn and Stolen Earth all released in the space of a few weeks, I wonder what it is about York. Is there something in the water?

This is an album which turned out to be well worth the wait. Fans of latter-day Marillion should love this, but it should also appeal to anyone that loves well-crafted music with plenty of emotional depth.

Old-fashioned types can buy the CD from http://riversea-band.com

The iPod generation can download it from http://riversea.bandcamp.com/album/out-of-an-ancient-world

Posted in Music, Record Reviews | Tagged , | 3 Comments

Maidu & Heather Findlay – The Way I See You

It’s been a long time coming, but the song co-written by Heather Findlay with the incognito experimental electronica collaboration going by the name Maidu is finally released as a download EP.

It’s labelled as “Dubstep/Grime”, but rock fans shouldn’t let that put them off. True, there aren’t any rock guitars in sight; instrumentally it’s all multi-layered atmospheric soundscapes, fluttering electronic effects and eastern-style percussion, with the addition of some upright bass and a little acoustic guitar. Heather’s fans certainly shouldn’t be disappointed by her contribution; a beautiful ethereal vocal with a seductive melody that gets stuck in your head after no more than a couple of listens. The chilled-out vibe is very different from her own 2011 guitar-based EP “The Phoenix Suite”, but arguably this is the more progressive record in the original sense of the word. It certainly shows a different side of her vocals and songwriting.

The full 6-track EP contains two additional mixes of the song by Tzfat and J Sparrow, plus three instrumental mixes. It’s all probably intended to be played on shuffle mixed in with other music rather than played all the way through in one sitting like a conventional album.

Heather has certainly suggested doing more electronica-based work in the future. If there’s any more to come in this vein, I’m looking forward to hearing it.

Posted in Music, Record Reviews | Tagged , | 5 Comments

Stolen Earth – A Far Cry From Home

Stolen Earth formed early in 2011 from the ashes of the much-loved York progressive rock band Breathing Space, who had split at the beginning of the year. They include no fewer than four members of Breathing Space’s short-lived final incarnation, including recently joined vocalist Heidi Widdop and guitarist Adam Dawson. Only the rock-solid rhythm section of Paul Teasdale and Barry Cassells remain from the linuep of Breathing Space’s final albums.

They quickly established a reputation as a powerful live act, with a strong set of songs including a couple performed during the last days of Breathing Space, which fuelled high expectations for their first album. That album, “A Far Cry From Home” is now out.

The band have successfully captured the big wide-screen sound of their live shows on record. The album gets off to a strong start with the opening driving rocker “Unnatural Disaster”, with more than a hint of Uriah Heep about it. John Sykes’ keyboards focus on atmosphere and texture rather than solos, with a lot of Hammond organ, leaving Adam Dawson’s guitar as the main lead instrument, and Heidi’s raw bluesy vocal style is a big contrast with most other bands in the scene.

Heidi’s semi-acoustic “Soul in a Jar” shows the bands’ softer side, featuring some very evocative low whistle. Other highlights include Adam’s “Mirror Mirror”, with some fantastic slide guitar. “Bitterness Fades” again has a Uriah Heep vibe, this time evoking their late-70s “Fallen Angel” era.

Adam Dawson sings lead on a couple of songs, with Heidi adding harmonies, one of them being the atmospheric “Silver Skies”, another album highlight, and one of the songs first performed live back in Breathing Space days. The album ends with the epic “Perfect Wave”, ending in extended guitar work-out.

Stolen Earth do a great line in epic wall-of-sound rock ballads with lengthy guitar solos, with many songs clocking in at seven, eight or even nine minutes in length. One or two shorter, punchier songs might have added some variety, but you can’t escape the fact the band do what they do well.

There’s a lot of Mostly Autumn’s Liam Davison in Adam Dawson’s guitar playing; indeed many of the instrumental passages have a similar vibe to parts of Davison’s 2011 solo album “A Treasure of Well-Set Jewels”. The combination of low whistle and Floydian atmospherics is also always going to evoke early Mostly Autumn, although Heidi Widdop’s has a very different vocal style, which is ironic when Heidi was actually a member of a very early lineup of that band.

One concern is that the similarity to early Mostly Autumn could be something of a double-edged sword. On the plus side, this album ought to appeal strongly to fans of Mostly Autumn’s early days, especially as that band have long since have moved on, adopting a harder-edged and more contemporary sound. But I’ve always felt that one reason for Breathing Space’s relative lack of success was that they never quite managed to establish a clear identity of their own. Hopefully Stolen Earth will manage to avoid falling into the same trap.

A couple of caveats aside, “A Far Cry From Home” is still a very good record. If you love well-crafted grown-up music performed by real singers and musicians putting their heart and soul into what they’re doing, I can strongly recommend this album.

The album is available from the Stolen Earth website.

Posted in Music, Record Reviews | Tagged | 6 Comments

Storm Corrosion

Storm Corrosion is the much anticipated Anglo-Swedish collaborative project between two of the biggest names in the contemporary progressive rock world, Opeth mainman Mikael Ã…kerfeldt and Steven Wilson of Porcupine Tree and myriad side-projects. While initial expectations might have been that they were going to do something along the lines of the prog-metal of their respective bands’ recent work, they soon made it clear it was going to be something altogether different.

The lengthy, atmospheric and sinister-sounding opener “Drag Ropes” sets the tone. With dominant sounds of acoustic guitar and mellotron plus piano, strings and woodwind it comes over as a soundtrack of a particularly spooky film, probably shot in grainy black-and-white. The film probably has subtitles, and everyone dies at the end.

It’s a record that owes as much to classical and folk music as it does to rock, and manages to combine a stripped-down minimalism with an ambitious cinematic scope. Save for one clattering outburst on “Hag”, accompanied by the only powerchords on the entire album, there is very little in the way of conventional rock drumming. But despite those dissonant strings and even the odd outbreak of pure white noise, it’s by no means an impenetrable record. It does need a few listens to fully appreciate it’s subtleties, which means it’s something you can listen to many times and keep discovering something new. It’s a work filled with moments of delicate beauty, whether it’s vocal harmonies or the sparse acoustic and electric guitar work.

There are elements of both musician’s other work, from Steve Wilson’s solo work to Opeth’s “Heritage” and “Damnation”. Parts of the instrumental “Lock Howl”, built around a rhythm loop and swirling keyboards recalls mid-period Tangerine Dream before giving way to percussion loops and disturbing discordant strings. There is also something of Talk Talk’s classic “Spirit of Eden” in it’s eschewing of conventional song structures in favour of soundscapes and textures, and that comparison is especially apparent on the dreamy closing track “Ljudet Innen”. There is also a bit of the spirit of Radiohead’s “Kid A” in it’s refusal to make any compromise towards commerciality or pander to audience expectations. In the unlikely event that you were still expecting Blackwater Park meets In Absentia, this is not the record you were looking for.

What we have is the sound of two of the progressive rock world’s most talented individuals following their combined muses wherever it takes them. It takes them and their listeners through some strange and exotic sonic landscapes, and it’s a more than worthwhile journey for anyone who chooses to follow. Bold and experimental, but still remaining accessible, it’s a genuinely progressive record in the true sense of the word.

Posted in Music, Record Reviews | Tagged , , | 1 Comment

The Reasoning – And Another Thing

The news of the disappearance of guitarist Owain Roberts, and the huge and ongoing fan campaign to spread the word and help find him has rather overshadowed the fact that the band have a new record out. Indeed, the band sent out the signed pre-order copies just days before he disappeared.

Although the band released a live album “The Bottle of Gettysburg” in 2011, and the album of reworkings of existing songs “Acoustically Speaking” late in 2010, this four track EP is the first release of all-new material since “Adverse Camber” two years ago. It’s also the first studio recording by the slimmed-down five piece version of the band with Owain Roberts as sole guitarist and Rachel Cohen as sole lead vocalist.

The opener “One By One” sets the tone. Beginning with chiming guitar and a vocal melody with an echo of their earlier “Dark Angel”, it combines atmospheric verses with a rockier chorus and a brief instrumental break of interplaying guitar and keys. It’s all over in less than four minutes, but seems to pack an awful lot of music into so short a time. In contrast, “Pale Criminal” is an out-and-out ballad. With another beautiful vocal melody from Rachel Cohen it’s a song that wouldn’t have sounded out of place on Karnataka’s “Delicate Flame of Desire”.

“Apophenia” and “20 Grams” round off the EP in similar vein, mid-tempo numbers combining delicate vocal melodies with restrained instrumental virtuosity from Owain Roberts and keyboardist Tony Turrell. Lyrics cover things like “the experience of seeing meaningful patterns or connections in random or meaningless data” and Duncan MacDougall’s rather strange theories of the weight of the human soul. Not your typical rock’n'roll fare at all.

The whole EP has a softer, more pared-back sound, with shorter songs reining in the prog-metal excesses of their recent past. There’s still plenty of depth in the arrangements, with a few nods to latter-day Marillion and Rush. But now Rachel Cohen’s vocals are given much more space to breathe, no longer in any danger of being swamped by the instrumentation. It’s a case of less being more. Even if none of the four songs quite reach the highest points of the first two albums, the result is nevertheless a more coherent and focussed effort than their last studio album, and it takes a very different musical direction from their early work.

The band are back in the studio now recording a full-length album slated for release in September, which will be the band’s first release under their new record deal Esoteric Antenna. In the meantime, this EP, their last self-released recording under the imprint of Comet Records, is available from the band’s website.

Posted in Music, Record Reviews | Tagged | 2 Comments

Mermaid Kiss – Circles of Fire

It’s been a long time since there’s been any activity from the Mermaid Kiss camp, but they’ve just released a new download single, “Circles of Fire”. It’s taken from their forthcoming album “Another Country”, the culmination of their “American Images” project.

Those of you who saw the semi-acoustic version of the band supporting Panic Room, Breathing Space or The Reasoning back in 2008 may well remember this song, as it featured in the live set. It’s a great showcase for Evelyn Downing’s very distinctive vocal style, Although acoustic instruments still feature heavily with Jamie Field’s guitar and Wendy Marks’ beautiful flute playing, here it’s expanded into a full band version culminating in a great solo from lead guitarist Pete West. As a slightly harder-edged Mermaid Kiss with more emphasis on guitar compared with the keyboard-led atmospherics of their last full-length album “Etarlis”, it’s in interesting taster for the forthcoming album.

It’s available for download from CD Baby.

Posted in Music, Music News, Record Reviews | Tagged | Comments Off

Heather Findlay and Chris Johnson – Live at the Café 68

Heather Findlay & Chris Johnson - Live at the Cafe 68“Live at the Café 68″ is York singer-songwriter Heather Findlay’s second release since leaving as lead singer of Mostly Autumn in 2010. Recorded before an intimate audience of just thirty people, it’s a stripped-down acoustic album featuring fellow singer-songwriter Chris Johnson on guitar and vocals.

It’s explicitly billed as a duo rather than a Heather Findlay solo project, and includes as many Chris Johnson-penned songs as it does Heather’s, drawn both from Chris’ time in Mostly Autumn and from a couple of his myriad other projects.

The album captures the atmosphere of the evening with a lot of between songs banter and the audience very prominent in the mix. If anything, the audience is perhaps a little too prominent, in that it reminds those of us who weren’t able to be there what we missed.

Opener “Phoenix” is the sole song taken from Heather’s début solo EP, with Heather singing the instrumental parts in the intro. It works so well in simplified acoustic form it feels as if that was the way the song was originally intended to be performed.

Without the power and energy of a full band, there’s nowhere for anyone to hide, and the whole thing stands on the quality of the songs and the performance. Heather has always been a class act as a vocalist, hitting that sweet spot balancing precision with emotional depth, whether it’s fronting the full-blown wall of sound of Mostly Autumn, or the more mellow and delicate acoustic vibes of Odin Dragonfly. The feel here is much closer to the latter. Chris Johnson also deserves a lot of credit for his guitar playing, adding far more richness and depth than you often get from a single acoustic guitar. It’s also interesting hearing Heather using wordless vocals to replace instrumental parts, such as the original clarinet line on “Blue Light”.

Apart from a cover of Gillian Welch’s “Dear Someone”, which is perhaps the weakest song on the entire album, the rest of the set is made up of reworkings of older songs from Heather’s and Chris’ respective songbooks. There are a couple of Mostly Autumn standards in “Caught in a Fold” and “Evergreen”, the latter working especially well acoustically. “Gaze”, a song originally hidden away on the bonus disk of Mostly Autumn’s “Heart Full of Sky” is sublime, as is the Odin Dragonfly number “Magpie”. The latter is a great example of Chris’ subtle but effective guitar playing, effortlessly combining the flute and guitar lines of the original into a single guitar part.

Although the focus is on Heather’s vocals with Chris Johnson adding harmonies, he does get to sing lead on a couple of songs, one being the jaunty “Out of Season”, originally by his band The Evernauts. The other, the dark and intense take on “The Dogs” from Chris’s project Halo Blind (née Parade) is one of the highlights, performed as a duet with Heather taking the lines originally sung by Anne-Marie Helder on the record, and ending with a few bars of Heather’s own “Red Dust”.

The Mostly Autumn number “Silver Glass” closes the album. The original version from “Heart Full of Sky” had been a piano-led number with Chris Johnson singing lead. Transposed from piano to guitar, and with Heather taking on the lead vocal, it turns into a spine-tingling performance that makes you wonder why Heather never sung lead on the original. Not that there’s anything wrong with Chris’ original vocal, but hearing Heather sing it lifts the song to another level.

Although I was unable to be there for the recording, people I’ve spoken to tell me it was a quite remarkable experience, and his record manages to capture a lot of that magic. There’s certainly something of the chill-out vibe of Odin Dragonfly’s “Offerings” on display here, and I think it’s fair to say that if you liked that album, you’ll probably like this. But there’s also a far greater emphasis here on Heather’s and Chris’ talents as songwriters, both with keen ears for very strong and memorable melodies.

“Live at the Café 68″ will be available for order from www.heatherfindlay.net from November 14th

Posted in Music, Record Reviews | Tagged , | 4 Comments