Music Blog

All the music-related posts gathered together in one place.

On Music vs. Lyrics

After too long a break, J Michael Neal is blogging again. Here’s what he has to say about Mark Knopfler’s latest album.

Knopfler has become far and away my favorite lyricist. Understand that my default setting is to pay no attention to a song’s lyrics whatsoever. Just because you hear me singing along doesn’t mean that I have the slightest idea what is being said. This has its upsides and downsides. It means that Dream Theater and Yes have irritated me a lot less than they might have, letting me just enjoy the music. It also means that it took me a long time to really appreciate Knopfler.

I actually think that the majority of ordinary music fans are more interested in the music than the lyrics. Unfortunately it’s the other way round for the majority of music critics, who, being writers, care more about the words. Hence we see the out of hand dismissal of bands like, well, Yes and Dream Theater, and excessive praise heaped upon the likes of Morrissey and Pulp, who’s work is sometimes so much about lyrics that they forgot to put any actual music in there. Strip away the lyrics from just about any of the indie bands praised by the NME, and you’re left with very formulaic four-chord plod where not only individual songs, but entire bands are completely indistinguisable.

As for Mark Knopfler, I’ve lost touch which what he’s been up to since the days of Dire Straits. I saw them live when they were at their commercial peak, when the Brothers in Arms album was CD all the gadget-obsessed yuppies always used to show off their expensive new stereos. Dire Straits unfortunately got tagged as Corporate AOR for the three-CDs-a-year crowd, filed alongside Phil Collins or Foreigner. They were really better than that. They’re overdue for critical reappraisal, and deserve to be remembered for works like “Telegraph Road” rather than the awful cheese of “Walk of Life”.

Posted in Music | 10 Comments

Mostly Autumn at Rhyl

Last Friday I saw the magnificent Mostly Autumn play the Welsh seaside town of Rhyl. For those not familiar with the place, Rhyl is an old-fashioned British seaside resort, where all the shops sell sticks or rock and Donald McGill postcards. This is the first time I’ve seen them since the departure of keyboard player Iain Jennings.

The Pavilion Theater seats about a thousand, and is a big venue for a band more used to playing clubs. While they didn’t fill it, they did manage to attract a fair-sized audience, both fans like me who’d travelled a fair distance, and plenty of locals who’d not seen them live before. When you used to seeing the band crammed into a tiny club stage with hardly enough space to move, it’s strange to see the eight of them spread out across the enormous theatre stage. There were one or two occasions where I feared Bryan would do a Frank Zappa and fall into the orchestra pit.

It’s also strange to see them in a seated venue. From my seat facing Bryan’s side of the stage, the sound mix had a little bit too much guitar, and not quite enough keyboards, which seemed to emphasise Iain Jennings’ absence. This does mean that flautist/keyboardist Angela Gordon has a much bigger role on stage, sharing Ian’s keyboard parts with new boy Chris Johnson, as well as playing a lot of flute. She’s also out front rather than being half-hidden at the back.

The two and a half hour set concentrated on old favourites. They started with the lengthy Floydian “The Last Climb”, which always seems to me to be a slightly odd choice for an opening number when the band have plenty of uptempo rockers in the setlist. The first half of the set was good enough, with the flute-driven rockers “Caught in a Fold” and “Dark Before the Dawn”, and a lengthy solo spot from Liam Davidson before “Spirit of Autumn Past”. Things really caught fire after the interval. After “Heart Life”, the ‘rocked-up celtic jig’ section finally got a large part of the audience out of their seats. (I think most of the people who criticise the band for ‘those awful jigs’ have never seen the band live). Then came an absolutely storming version of “Never the Rainbow”, with Heather and backing singer Olivia Sparnenn singing alternate lines, followed by the call-and-response between Olivia and Bryan’s guitar. In complete contrast, it’s nice to hear “Shrinking Violet” restored to the set, which had been absent the last couple of times I’ve seen them. The one real surprise was “Close my Eyes” from the band’s debut album. They closed the main set with a magnificent “Carpe Diem”. Encores were “Heroes Never Die” and, of course, the epic “Mother Nature”.

While it was sad to hear about Iain’s departure, his absence hasn’t diminished the band’s live performances. If you get a chance to see them live, go. You won’t be disappointed.

Posted in Live Reviews, Music | Tagged , | Comments Off

Live music coming up

Last weekend I’ve broken the four month drought of live music by seeing a kick-ass performance by Hayseed Dixie, for which I still haven’t written a review.

Next up is the always wonderful Mostly Autumn at Rhyl, for which I’ve now got my accomodation sorted. I’ve got a front row seat, so this should be a good one.

Now I’ve got to decide whether I’ve got the stamina for the DEMU Showcase, Queensrÿche and Journey on three consecutive days in June! So far I’ve got a ticket for Journey, but not Queensrÿche. There’s also Zappa plays Zappa two days earlier, for which there also still seem to be tickets available. That would make three gigs and one model railway exhibition in five days. Can I cope with this without needing a week off work to recover?

Update: I’ve managed to get a seat in row D for Zappa plays Zappa, and on the basis that Owen and Mike Foley are probably going to Sunday’s Queensrÿche show, I’ve just ordered a ticket for that as well.

Posted in Music | Comments Off

The Devil’s Tritone?

Is this why fundies call heavy metal The Devil’s Music?

On the surface there might appear to be no link between Black Sabbath, Wagner’s Gotterdammerung, West Side Story and the theme tune to the Simpsons.

But all of them rely heavily on tritones, a musical interval that spans three whole tones, like the diminished fifth or augmented fourth. This interval, the gap between two notes played in succession or simultaneously, was branded Diabolus in Musica or the Devil’s Interval by medieval musicians.

A rich mythology has grown up around it. Many believe that the Church wanted to eradicate the sounds from its music because it invoked sexual feelings, or that it was genuinely the work of the Devil.

It is a mythology much beloved of long-haired guitar wizards.

When will the fundamentalist loons start demanding that the theme tune of The Simpsons be banned?

According to an interview I’ve read (can’t remember where), Tony Iommi came up with the riff of “Black Sabbath” while the band were rehearsing next door to a cinema showing horror films. Someone suggested that if people were paying to see scary films, they’d pay to hear scary music. So he picked up his guitar and played some tritones.

Meanwhile, Finland’s Eurovision Entry appears to be upsetting some Greek fundies who really need to get a life.

A group of Greek protesters known as the Hellenes have called on the Finnish government to intervene: “We ask the Finnish Commission of the Eurovision Song Contest to cancel the procedure and choose another song. This evil and satanic Finnish band is not welcome in Greece.”

Not sure whether their song “Hard Rock Hallelujah” contains any of the dreaded tritones.

Posted in Music | 2 Comments

Music for 2006

Unlike the flurry of gigs at the tail end of last year, I’ve gone three months without any live music, which is three months too long. But now I do now have some gigs to look forward to. So far I’ve got tickets for Hayseed Dixie (recommended by Ginger) in Manchester on 23rd April, Mostly Autumn in Rhyl on 5th May, and Journey (how long since they last played the UK?) at Manchester Apollo on 5th June.

Currently listening to Journey’s new album “Generations“. Some great material, and a lot rocker than other more recent releases, but why does new vocalist Steve Auguri only sing half the songs?

As for Hayseed Dixie, the only music of theirs I’ve heard is their fantastic cover of Queen’s “Fat Bottomed Girls”, which appeared on a recent cover disk of Classic Rock magazine, and completely blew away everything else on that CD. Anyone recommend which is their best album?

Posted in Music | Comments Off

Music for the Ronry

You think your own country has a terrible music scene, dominated by cheesy pap? It could be worse. You could live in North Korea

A graduate of the North’s prestigious Pyongyang University of Music and Dance, Kim was allowed to further his studies at the Tchaikovsky Music Academy in Moscow in 1995 at government expense.

A year later, he came into contact with jazz for the first time.

“One day, one music class was cancelled, so I went to a cafe near my school to drink a cup of coffee, and music (coming) from the speakers there _ a type that I had never heard before _ thrilled me”, Kim said.

So, which jazz great did he hear? Bird? Coltrane? Monk? Rollins?

“I asked the cafe owner what kind of music that was, and he replied it was `A Comme Amour’ by pop, classical and jazz pianist Richard Clayderman. It was too good, and that began to change my life”.

Richard Clayderman? “Too good, and that began to change my life”?? A chilling insight into the cultural desert that is North Korea.

Posted in Music | 1 Comment

Vote Troll!

What do you get when you cross Rammstein, The Darkness, and the props departments of Peter Jackson’s Lord of the Rings? Something like Finlands’s entry to the Eurovision Song Contest. Those Vikings are crazy, I tell you….

I’d love to see Britain enter a proper rock song rather than the processed eurocheese we usually come up with. Mötorhead would be the ideal entry, especially if they do something completely uncompromising, along the lines of “Killed By Death”.

On the other hand, perhaps The Darkness would be the ideal entry; they’d actually be crazy enough to do it.

Posted in Music | Comments Off

A Goth Future?

First Dagworth, next the world! That’s what The Guardian’s Dave Simpson seems to think.

“Most youth subcultures encourage people to drop out of school and do illegal things,” she says. “Most goths are well educated, however. They hardly ever drop out and are often the best pupils. The subculture encourages interest in classical education, especially the arts. I’d say goths are more likely to make careers in web design, computer programming … even journalism.”

Still doesn’t explain why I know more goths through the world of model railways than through RPGs.

Posted in Music | 1 Comment

Railroad Earth – Elko

There is no British band remotely equivalent to Railroad Earth. They play what I think is called ‘progressive bluegrass’. It sounds like one part American folk, one part prog-rock, and one part jam band. RRE are in their element on stage, as this double live set shows. Some of their songs extend to 10 or even 15 minutes long, but never descent into directionless noodling, even though some contain two, three or even four solos. Some of the most amazing solos come from violin player Tim Carbone.

Although there’s no hint of this on the liner notes, Scott tells me it’s recorded entirely on acoustic instruments, although a lot of it’s fed through guitar affects. If you didn’t know, you’d swear most of the guitars were electric, and John Skehan’s mandolin was an electric piano. Todd Sheaffer’s distorted guitar even has some Rotheryesque moments. High spot for me is the lengthy “Hunting Song”, with Schaeffer and Carbone swapping solos. The whole album is pretty amazing stuff, some incredible virtuosity, and I wish I could get the chance to see them live.

Posted in Music, Record Reviews | Tagged | 1 Comment

David Gilmour – On An Island

Gilmour’s third solo album sees the Pink Floyd guitarist in mellow chill-out mode. It took me a while to really get into this one; at first, a lot of it sounded like the sort of material that I’d class as filler if it appeared on a Mostly Autumn disk. But Gilmour hasn’t quite descended into Eric Clapton pipe-and-slippers mode yet, and repeated plays reveal a lot more depth. Nothing really catches fire, but the album does turn into something of a slow-burner.

In places there’s a strong feel of “Meddle” thirty five years ago, and ultimately the only real clunker is the lumpen blues jam “This Heaven”. Naturally there’s plenty of Gilmour’s signature guitar playing throughout, although anyone expecting a new ‘Comfortably Numb’ might have to look elsewhere. On the instrumental “Red Sky at Night”, Gilmour demonstrates that he can play the saxophone as well as the guitar. He’s managed to recruit an impressive list of guest appearances, including David Crosby and Graham Nash, Phil Manzenera, Richard Wright, Jools Holland, Georgie Fame, Robert Wyatt and Guy Pratt. Overall, while this isn’t an ‘instant’ album, listen to it half a dozen times and it will start to get under your skin.

Posted in Music, Record Reviews | Tagged | Comments Off