Music Blog

All the music-related posts gathered together in one place.

Breathing Space, Lowdham, 7-Feb-2009

Another weekend, more long-distance gigging.  This time I found myself making a three hour train journey across the snow-covered east midlands countryside to see York’s Breathing Space play in the Nottinghamshire town of Lowdham, for what turned out to be the first sold-out gig I’ve been to for more than a year. I’d booked a room at the B&B attached to the village pub, where I found many of the usual suspects in the bar. Yes, it was going to be one of those evenings

The Village Hall in Lowdham isn’t your typical rock venue. In fact, it was probably one strangest venues I’ve been to.  I’ve known other gigs that have been seated with tables, but never with an pre-arranged seating plan.  In this case the organisers put everyone with non-local postcodes down the front, on the basis that we were the hardcore fans who had travelled a long way.  The village hall lacks a licenced bar, although they were providing coffee and biscuits.  However, they did have a rather splendid arrangement with the pub over the road with excellent selection of real ales, whereby you could bring your pint into the venue provided.

With a venue that’s not associated with rock bands I wondered what the sound would be like. I needn’t have worried, the acoustics of the hall were excellent, and the sound engineer, perhaps because he’s more used to folk acts, resisted the temptation to turn the PA up to heavy metal volumes. Breathing Space always sound their best when mixed for clarity rather than volume, especially given the power of Olivia Sparnenn’s voice.  Those big soaring ballads don’t work so well when turned up to eleven.

Breathing Space delivered a superb set, as good as I’ve seen them play. They had to rearrange a few songs following the recent departure of sax and wind synth player John Hart, mostly with Mark Rowan filling the gaps on guitar. There seemed to be a few other subtle changes; I thought Iain Jennings used a lot more Hammond organ sounds that at previous gigs.  The setlist was much the same as last year, but included a couple of new songs which will appear on the third album due in the middle of the year. The slightly proggy ‘Butterflies and White Feathers’, which they first played towards the end of last year gets better and better each time I hear it, and the newer ‘Below the Radar’, which I’d not heard live before, is a powerful hard rocker. They closed, as usual, with a powerful version of the old Mostly Autumn classic, ‘The Gap Is Too Wide’, which always brings out the goosebumps.

All this was enthusiastically received by an audience that wasn’t made up of existing fans, wasn’t a ‘prog’ audience, and quite possibly wasn’t really even a rock audience. Which all goes to prove there’s an audience out their for Breathings Space’s brand of progressive-tinged classic rock if people are aware of their existence.

Posted in Live Reviews, Music | Tagged , | 4 Comments

Make Your Own Bus Slogan

 A web-based bus slogan generator to make your own version of the infamous “atheist buses” you can see in the UK.  Unfortunately the full lyrics of Marillion’s “This is the 21st Century” don’t fit.

We’ll start with the rather obvious H.P.Lovecraft version

One for this Saturday’s gig in Lowdham

 And finally, the obligatory gamer one:

Posted in Games, Music, Science Fiction, Travel & Transport | 2 Comments

Panic Room, Swansea and London

I started my live music for 2009 with two gigs on two nights by the same band, in two completely different cities.

While Friday night’s gig in Swansea was really a warm-up for the high-profile London show the next day, it also featured a one-off guest appearance from violinist Liz Prendegast, who’d played on several songs on the album “Visionary Position”.

The Garage is quite a nice little venue; capacity of perhaps 200, although it was nowhere near full. Unfortunately the gig did suffer from a disappointingly high level of background chatter which was noticeable during the quiet bits. And everyone hung at the back of the room despite Anne-Marie Helder trying to persuade people to move forward.

Panic Room’s set suffered badly from technical glitches, the worst of which was Anne-Marie’s microphone not being switched on at the very beginning, resulting in a false start to ‘Electra City’. But the band managed to rise above the gremlins, and played an entertaining and varied set lasting not far short of two hours. While they played some  favourites from their debut album, such as the atmospheric epic ‘Endgame’ and the arabesque ‘Apocalypstick’, those amounted to something like a third of the set.

Some of the newer material they’d been playing at the end of last year have already become live favourites, such as the spiky guitar-driven rocker ‘Go’ and the industrial-sounding ‘Black Noise’, and they added another couple of brand new songs for their first live airing; of those ’5th Amendment’ was the most impressive.  Anne-Marie did her customary mid-set acoustic solo spot, of which the a cappella ‘Hadditfeel’ was the highlight. They ended with their groove-orientated cover of Led Zeppelin’s ‘No Quarter’, including a few bars of ‘Kashmir’ for good measure. When she joined them on stage, Liz’s electric violin added an extra dimension to the sound, especially on the ‘Apocalypstick’ and ‘No Quarter’. I’d love to see her accompany the band for a whole tour.

Saturday’s gig at The Peel was the replacement for the show in April cancelled due to power failure, and this rescheduled gig attracted the largest crowd I’ve seen at a Panic Room gig to date, while I don’t think they quite sold out, the place was pretty much full. Support was prog veterans Jump, who delivered a highly entertaining set; a band I’m getting to like more and more every time I see them. John Dexter Jones is a great frontman; while he looks a bit like Morrissey,  he sounds more like Fish; you can certainly hear the influence of both Marillion and Fish’s solo material in their sound.

Panic Room then delivered the best performance I’ve seen them play to date. Playing a shorter set than the previous night, they went pretty much full tilt all the way through, high energy levels, fantastically tight, and hugely appreciated by the crowd.

What I love about this band is that while they’re all clearly virtuoso musicians, they always play exactly what the songs need and no more; they never descend into the sort of self-indulgent noodling that ‘prog’ is all-too frequently accused of.  And I think the fact that I’ve got several of their new songs stuck in my head means they’re capable of writing memorable songs that ought to appeal to mainstream audiences. And after many years as a backing singer to Rachel Jones in Karnataka and Heather Findlay in Mostly Autumn, Anne-Marie Helder proves she’s in the same league as either of them when it comes to fronting a band herself.

Their next gig is in Stocksbridge near Sheffield in March.

Posted in Live Reviews, Music | Tagged , , | Comments Off

Which 70s and 80s bands deserve a critical rehabilitation?

This is prompted by some comments deep within the comments thread of a rather silly Alan McGee post on The Guardian Music Blog by Jasonaparkes and Jforbes, which speculated as to which half-forgotten or critically maligned acts deserve a non-ironic critical rehabilitation.

Not that I’m talking about mainstream critical opinion here, not the opinion of actual rock fans.

  • Dire Straits: If you don’t come from Britain you’ll probably be amazed at the way Dire Straits have acquired the critical pariah status they have.  They tend to get lumped in with Phil Collins as the music people who bought two or three albums a year listened to, while all the self-described cool people were busy listening to jangly indie. While it’s true that, at least around the time of the mega-selling “Brothers in Arms” that they did attract the attention of very large numbers of annoying people called ‘Kevin’, that’s not a fair way to judge the actual music.  While their music suffered from the occasional lapse of taste, a distressing proportion of which got released as singles to be lapped up by the Kevins, most of their albums, especially “Love Over Gold” stand up well; some very witty lyrics and fantastic guitar playing.
  • Supertramp: I have to confess all-but forgetting this band until I recently picked up their live double “Paris” a few months back.   Seventies soft-rock has never been the most fashionable of genres, but I’d forgotten just how good they were.   Another band for which their commercial singles don’t really represent what they were about; it’s the prog epics like “Crime of the Century” and “Fools Overture” where they shine.
  • Styx: Another band I had to completely reassess recently.   When I saw them supporting Deep Purple a couple of years back their barnstorming live performance completely blew the headliners away. Sometimes big vocal harmonies and hard rock guitars go together well.  The 70s production values of their albums sound a bit tame now, but as they showed live, the songs themselves stand up.
  • Journey: Yes, I’m talking about the 80s commercial version of the band rather than the early 70s jazz/prog outfit. Yes, some of their power ballads descended deep into Camembert territory, but they could also be a great hard rock band when they want to, another case of listen to the albums, not just the single. And Neil Schon is an incredible guitarist – his jazz-metal shredding sound like no-one else.

Posted in Music | Tagged , , , | 6 Comments

Goodbye to The Astoria


(Photo by Chris Walkden)

So it’s farewall to The Astoria in Charing Cross Road, which closed last week to make way for a new station as part of Crossrail.

It was grungy, it smelled of sweat and stale beer, some of the door staff were knuckle-draggers, the beer was overpriced and rented rather than bought, and the toilets were hideous. But it was rock and roll, and we all loved it anyway.

The Guardian Music Blog has a lengthy comment thread in which people share their memories of the place. Since I’ve been living in Manchester during the period while I’ve been going to lots of gigs, I haven’t been there as often as some. My fondest memory of the place was the Mostly Autumn album launch back in 2007. Blue Öyster Cult was a great one back in 2002.

One hopes there will be a decent replacement – I’m confident that if there is a market for an Astoria-sized venue somewhere in central London that one will appear. I’m sure the capital could manage with one fewer venue for Andrew Lloyd-Webber musicals. Not that it would replace the Astoria overnight – it takes years for a venue to acquire character, and decades to acquire a history. But it will happen.

Posted in Music | Comments Off

Electric Nose’s top 10

Electric Nose takes a diversion from trains, and posts his top ten album list for 2008

His comments on the current state of the mainstream make my most acidic comments look mild by comparison.

I hear a lot of talk about the woefully plastic nature of modern music. The crass commercialism of X-Factor and similar chav-fests. The lowest common denominator boybands and ten-a-penny corporate-indie ensembles with NME-compliant haircuts. The cheap-to-run ‘Interchangeable Emmas’ of the karaoke diva world. All true. All stereotypes, of course, but all true. Yet this is just one part of the world of music. In fact, I’d suggest, this is more the world of television than the world of music. I’ve no doubt the big money comes from folk tapping out premium-rate voting numbers on their phones while revenue from people actually buying ’20 Menstrual Greats’ from Asda probably barely covers the ‘fruit and flowers’ these days.

Electric Nose doesn’t allow comments (Bah!) so I’ll have to use my own blog instead.  Nice to see four of my own top ten in the list, including The Reasoning’s wonderful “Dark Angel”. More significantly, all but one of the others are albums I’ve not actually heard; some of them are almost certainly going to be worth checking out.

Demains I realise I have actually seen live – they supported Anathema back in November.  Due to a combination of Northern Rail playing silly buggers and the most slow-moving queue to enter a venue I’ve ever seen, I didn’t get to see the start of their set, but I don’t remember being blown away by them live.  But a lot of other people whose views I respect like the album.

Posted in Music | Tagged , | 2 Comments

The Long Tail

There’s been a lot of talk on the interweb tubes recently about The Long Tail advocated by Chris Anderson, which suggests that businesses can be profitable serving niche markets rather than concentrating on big hits.  Since my musical tastes are well outside the commercial mainstream, I’ve got a vested interest in the long tail – I’d much rather listen to someone like Panic Room than Leona Lewis.

Helienne Lindvall, writing in the Guardian, cites a survey that appears to question the existence of the long tail, but on closer examination appears to show that’s she hasn’t really understood what the long tail theory says; you’ll get no understanding of the length or width of the tail when you’re not looking below the neck. Quite a few commenters have pointed this out, although you should ignore the twit who equates going to a gig where a member of the band greets you by name with ‘giving money to buskers’.

The Jinni Blog makes a very imporatant point, that the real importance of the Long Tail is not economic, but cultural. If you’re only interested in the size of Simon Cowell’s bank balance or which corporate indie clone bands get playlisted on Radio One, then you might not care about the long tail.  But as far as I’m concerned, the long tail is where most of the worthwhile music can be found.  More importantly, it’s where the mainstream will be getting it’s new ideas from.

Just about all the music I love lies deep within the long tail.  Of my top ten albums of 2008, no less than seven were purchased directly from the band, either from their websites or from merchandise stands at gigs. And four of those were pre-orders, where fans pay for an album before it’s recorded, instead of the band getting an advance from a record company.

Long live the tail.

Posted in Music | Tagged , | 3 Comments

First Up Against the Wall When the Revolution Comes!

The BBC has a list of so-called “tastemakers” who tell us the music that we’re going to be force-fed with over the next twelve months. Their 15 pundits are the A-list of all the people responsible for the utter crapness of the mainstream music scene with it’s wall-to-wall landfill indie and Asda-pop – the controller of Radio One, the appalling editor of the NME, the producer of “Later with Jools Holland”, they’re all there.

I wonder if the people who’s annual record purchases consist of 2 or 3 CDs a year from Asda don’t realise that all the music the mainstream will hear is pre-selected by such a small clique of people, and how cosy the relationship between the BBC, the major record companies and the music press has become. Do they know they’re sheep, or do they just not care?

Personally I think BBC radio and TV is failing to satisfy the public service remit of the BBC charter by it’s marginalisation of all but a narrow range of genres of popular music, and I find it hard to justify the existence of some BBC radio channels in their present form.

Posted in Music | Tagged , , | 5 Comments

Farewell to The Storm

After many years, the original Karnataka mailing list TheStorm is finally closing it’s virtual doors. Moderator HippyDave will be leaving the archives up there in read-only form, but new discussions should be directed to the web forums for the three bands that arose from the ashes of the old lineup, the new Karnataka, Panic Room and The Reasoning.

Many thanks to HippyDave for moderating this list, along with a great many others (where does he find the time?)

Through a case of very bad timing, I discovered the music of the original Karnataka just before they unexpectedly split up, and never got to see that incarnation of the band live. I joined the mailing list just after the split to find out what on earth had happened. I didn’t actually find out, but did meet a great number of really cool people, many of whom I’ve subsequently met at gigs.

And it was on that list that I first heard of the various successor bands. Without that I doubt that I’d have travelled down to Swansea in the aftermath of a hurricane to witness The Reasoning’s very first gig, or to Lydney in the remote depths of the Forest of Dean to witness the first live appearance of Panic Room.

So a final farewell to the list, but almost certainly not farewell to anyone on it, who I’m sure we’ll see on one or more forums, and at gigs.

Posted in Music | Tagged | Comments Off

Best (and worst) Gigs of 2008

Some of my highlights (and low points) of the 30+ live gigs I attended this year.

Most hard-rocking gig by a newish band
The Reasoning, when they blew the roof off Crewe Limelight. I’ve seen this band six times this year, and they’ve never disappointed. This one was the best of the six.

Most hard-rocking gig by a bunch of grizzled veterans
The mighty Uriah Heep at Manchester Academy 2. They were good the last couple of times I’ve seen them playing greatest hits sets. This time they took the gamble of playing their new album “Wake the Sleeper” in it’s entirety, which might have flopped if the album hadn’t been up to scratch. But with an excellent album, it turned into a triumph.

Most emotionally moving gig
This has to be Breathing Space at Mansfield. This was about two weeks after the death of lead singer Olivia Sparnenn’s father Howard from a brain tumour. The whole show was intensely moving, especially the final encore of the Mostly Autumn song “The Gap is Too Wide”. Not long after this I lost my temper with a Guardian Journalist who insisted that “Amy Winehouse is an icon because she can articulate pain and heartbreak in her songs”. He just doesn’t get it.

Most totally bonkers gig
Has to be The Mars Volta at Manchester Apollo. A three hour set, no support, no interval, and they played right up to the curfew without going off and coming back for an encore. And the whole thing was one continuous jam. Despite owning all four of their studio albums, I recognised very little of what they actually played. It was intense, complex and very, very loud. Even after nine months I’m still not quite sure what to make of it.

Worst performance by a so-called classic artist.
Andy Fairweather-Low at the Cambridge Rock Festival. “I’m a great sixties icon – you have to bow down and worship me”. Reminded me of The Kinks at the 1981 Reading Festival in 1981, and not in a good way. Tedious set of 50s and 60s covers, made no attempt to connect with the audience, and gave me the impression he was was playing for the benefit of Radio Caroline rather than the people in the hall.

The gig that didn’t actually happen
Panic Room at the Peel where the power failed, and we didn’t get any music apart from 20 minutes of the support band. Fortunately I did get to see the excellent Panic Room a further three times, and there’s a rematch of the cancelled gig on January 31st next year – see you there!

Posted in Music | Tagged , , , , | 8 Comments